The 25 highest-value expenditure proposals in the budget speech for 2023 had a total allocation of LKR 49.3 billion. But for proposals to the value of 43.8 billion (89%) the government was not able to provide information on progress, according to the annual evaluation done by Verité Research.
The state of Information
In 2022, progress was not known on proposals that had 93% of allocated funds. Since 2017 these last two years have been the two worst in terms of information available on the highest-value budget proposals.
Looking at by number rather than the value of the 25 proposals, information was made available to assess the progress of 18 proposals (72%). This is a notable improvement from 2022, which was an all-time low on information disclosure — only 29% of the proposals (7 out of 24) could be evaluated for progress based on the information provided. The 18 proposals with progress information available for 2023 amounted to only LKR 5.4 billion – just 11% of the total allocation.
Visibility is particularly low around budgeted social welfare payments, which received the highest allocations as budget proposals in the last two years: LKR 26.8 billion in 2022 and LKR 43 billion in 2023. In both years the government failed to disclose information on the progress of these proposals.
This deficiency in information is also apparent from Sri Lanka’s score in the Open Budget Survey (OBS). The budget transparency score (based on availability, substance and timeliness) was 37 out of 100 in 2023, well below the global average of 45. The OBS is the world’s only independent, comparative assessment of public access to central government budget information.
The state of implementation
By number of proposals, only 16% (4 out of 25) were fully implemented in 2023. An example of non-implementation is the budget proposal to spend LKR 500 million to improve child nutrition.
The Ministry of Finance (MoF) informed Verité Research that the Ministry of Health (MoH) was responsible for implementing this proposal. The MoH responded to an RTI request on this proposal stating that it had submitted a proposal requesting funds from the National Budget Department of the MoF but had not received the funds.
The findings are contained in the latest end-year budget promises assessment of Verité Research, which assessed progress up to 31 December 2023. The document also makes recommendations for improvement.
Recommendations
The document sets out several recommendations for improvement. Three highlights are to:
- Improve oversight of budget implementation by the Ministry of Finance (MoF) and legislative committees, such as the Committee on Public Accounts (COPA) and Committee on Public Finance (COPF).
- Publish supporting documents with assumptions and analysis behind the proposals so as to ensure they are well-formulated and achievable.
- Comply with proactive disclosure requirements of the RTI Act and disclose timely information on the ministry websites.
For more information about the proposals tracked, responsible agencies and other findings, visit the online dashboard ‘Budget Promises’, housed under the PublicFinance.lk platform of Verité Research: https://dashboards.publicfinance.lk/budget-promises/
